Compare two appraisals and see exactly where they part ways
Two appraisals of the same property can land on different values because the appraisers chose different comparable sales, rated condition differently or weighed the approaches another way. Comparing appraisals of different properties raises similar questions. Put both reports in one Search+ workspace and ask about one difference at a time; the answer cites each report, so you can read both appraisers' reasoning next to each other.
Creating an account needs no payment.
Last updated October 2026
How to compare appraisals in one workspace
- Upload both reports with clear file names
Add each appraisal, named by appraiser or date, plus any review or reconsideration letter. Clear names make it obvious which report each citation points to.
- List the comparison criteria
In Workspace Context, write the points to compare, for example "effective date, comparables, adjustments for size and condition, approaches developed, final value." Each question in the workspace follows that list.
- Ask one criterion at a time
Start with "Which comparables appear in both reports, and which appear in only one?" and read the cited grids before moving to adjustments and reconciliation.
Comparison questions to ask
Do the two appraisals use any of the same comparable sales, and if so, are they adjusted differently?
How does each report rate the property's condition and quality, and what reasons does each give?
What is the effective date of each appraisal, and does either apply a market time adjustment?
Which valuation approaches did each appraiser develop, and how much weight did each give them?
What final value does each report reach, and what reasons do the commentaries give for it?
Where appraisals usually differ
Different comps are the most common source of different values. Check distance, sale date and similarity to the subject for each.
Two appraisers can adjust the same feature by different amounts. Compare the explanations given for the largest adjustments.
A different rating changes which comps fit and how they are adjusted, so read each report's description of the property.
Appraisals made months apart reflect different market conditions. Compare the dates before comparing the values.
Search+ writes the comparison in chat and cites each appraisal it draws on, so you can open both excerpts and decide for yourself.
Comparison points for appraisals
| Comparison point | Why it matters | A question to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Effective date | Market conditions change over time | How far apart are the effective dates? |
| Comparables | Drive most of the value | Which comps are unique to each report? |
| Adjustments | Explain differences from the subject | Where do the adjustments for the same feature differ? |
| Condition rating | Affects comps and adjustments | Do the reports rate condition differently? |
| Approaches used | Can shift the reconciled value | Did both develop the cost or income approach? |
| Final value | The number that gets used | What reasons does each give for its final value? |
What an appraisal comparison in Search+ is
Comparing appraisals in Search+ means asking a comparison question across the reports in a workspace and reading a chat answer that cites each report. It explains differences in writing; it is not a redline, a side-by-side file or a new valuation.
Questions about comparing appraisals
Can Search+ compare an original appraisal with a second opinion?
Will it tell me which appraisal is right?
Can it compare the adjustment grids?
Can I compare appraisals for different properties?
Will the comparison catch every difference?
See why two appraisals disagree
Start a workspace, upload both appraisals, and ask where they differ.
Start a workspace